Maddy Goto

A little late to the party, perhaps, but in the last six months I have discovered Percival Everett ... three books in, many more to go. While the themes across all three were consistent and serious, each book was spectacularly different and brilliantly put together. I was entertained on multiple levels and left with much to contemplate after each one.
Shortlisted for the 2024 Booker prize, James revisits Mark Twain’s Adventures of Huckleberry Finn, but offers a perspective of the story through the eyes and voice of Jim the escaped slave. Everett
cleverly uses code-switching, where James uses ‘slave vernacular’ to make the white people around him feel more comfortable, despite being able to covertly read and write and having intellectual imaginary conversations with various philosophers. The comedy of this role-playing sits within a fast-paced adventure story, and alongside the horrors and dehumanisation of chattel slavery. I reread the original Twain novel after this one, as I was curious to see how aligned they were. While the main events were the same, with both books focused on two runaways rafting down the Mississippi, the ending of James has an unexpected twist.
Next, I picked up The Trees. I am still in awe of how an author is able to create a page-turning narrative, exposing the thousands of brutal lynchings that took place from the late 1800s to the mid-1900s in the USA, yet achieve laugh-out-loud humour over and over again, not least from the names given to his characters: from Cad Fondle, the coroner, and Helvetica Quip, the medical examiner, to Wheat Bryant, a trucker from Money, Mississippi.
I didn’t love Erasure immediately but did by the end. This one was a trickier read, telling the story of Thelonius ‘Monk’ Elison, a writer who seeks to rectify the rejection of his work due to it not being “black enough”. This happens with Everett’s customary humour and satire, so cleverly positioned inside something deadly serious.
Suffice to say, Percival Everett has a new fan.
Alison Madelaine

Just recently, I reread 1984 by George Orwell. Even though I had read it before, I was still struck by how disturbing it remains, even in 2025. How did the author know we would have screens in our homes that listen to and monitor us? Fake news and AI-generated media content are other scary reminders of how relevant 1984 still is. And without wishing to get too political, it seems that the kind of unchecked power described in the novel is still an issue today.
In a similar, depressing vein, earlier in the year I devoured Juice by Tim Winton. After a catastrophic climate-related disaster, those living in certain parts of Australia must live underground during the summer due to extreme heat. The narrator moves between his present and past, describing his recruitment into a mysterious group targeting those they deem responsible for the environmental disaster. This is a chunky, doorstop of a book, but if you like dystopian stories and Tim Winton, I recommend it!
On to a more cheerful choice, I have always loved books told in diary entries or letters, so I really loved The Correspondent by Virginia Evans. The main character, Sybil Van Antwerp is retired, and after living a full life, she writes letters to various family members and others, including well-known authors (to let them know what she thinks of their books). This story is both funny and heartbreaking at the same time. I could not put it down.
Ying Sng

“Don’t hand this book out to just anyone!” my friend Lisa warned after I’d lent her The Vegetarian by Han Kang. The book is about a young South Korean woman who decides to become a vegetarian after recurring dreams of animals dying. Her decision causes great displeasure to her husband and family. Told in three parts through her husband, her brother- in-law and her sister, the whole book is a disturbing portrayal of a cry for help that not only falls on deaf ears but is met with brutal consequences.
Lisa is right. It’s not for the faint-hearted, but I thought it was provocative and worth reading.
John Boyne’s The Elements is a collection of four interconnected short stories: Water, Earth, Fire and Air. Published over 18 months, reading them felt like tuning in to watch weekly TV episodes rather than binging a whole season. Each book is from the perspective of an enabler, an accomplice, a perpetrator or a victim of abuse. Whilst Water and Air were enjoyable to read, Earth and Fire dealt with complex moral and emotional themes and explored challenging aspects of the human response to trauma. Although each story stands alone, reading the books in order reveals the connections between the characters and delivers a rather satisfying ending.
Finally, a book I have had to set aside unfinished. Whilst The Vegetarian left a lasting impression, the subject matter in Fang Si Chi’s First Love Paradise by Taiwanese author Lin Yi-Han asked more than I was ready to give. Knowing it drew from the author’s own experience, the story – centred on a schoolgirl’s ‘relationship’ with a revered teacher who is also her neighbour – was emotionally overwhelming. I may have to bury my copy in the backyard; Lisa would agree that this is not to be passed around lightly.
Kevin Wheldall

Is reader’s block a thing, like writer’s block? Who knows?
But I had it again for several months until it finally broke. I must have started at least three novels only to put them aside. Not that I had not been reading; I had of course been reading lots on screens, just not actual books. The books I discarded were not bad; the problem was me. (This may not have been unconnected to another bout of ill-health, leading to my being hospitalised and diagnosed with diabetes. Such is life.)
So, what stopped the rot or rather the drought? A new novel by the estimable Peter May, whose brilliant Chessmen trilogy (mentioned in an earlier issue) has now been extended to a fourth book, The Black Loch. It is a tour de force serving as both excellent novel in its own right while incorporating a startling “j’accuse” to the Scottish salmon farming industry. The images of farmed salmon half-eaten by sea lice, which are tiny crustaceans, will leave you unsettled about the prospect of ever eating farmed salmon again. I have no idea whether such a grim picture obtains in the Australian salmon industry but Booker Prize winner, Richard Flanagan’s book, Toxic: The Rotting Underbelly of the Tasmanian Salmon Industry suggests that it is little better.
I followed this up with a rather strange short story, published online, by Margaret Atwood and entitled My Evil Mother. It is about a woman whose mother believes herself to be a witch ... or perhaps she was. It was an odd read and quite disconcerting.
The Good Turn by Dervla McTiernan, which I also read online, was an amusing follow up to her previous crime novels; nothing special and it rang no particular bells. Imagine my consternation, then, when I came to add it to my BookBuddy file of books read. I had apparently already read it in 2020! This reminded me of a comment from an old friend of mine who remarked that there was very little need to buy any more books because he had hundreds already and could remember nothing about them. I know the feeling and here was the proof.
Finally, imagine if you were to read a book by Dickens in which David Copperfield met Oliver Twist or Austen’s Emma Woodhouse met Elizabeth Bennet... The many fans of Elizabeth Strout will be delighted with her latest novel, Tell Me Everything, in which two of her characters from two, until now, separate series of books, do just that. The irascible Olive Kitteridge meets that gentle soul, Lucy Barton, and they gossip and swap stories. And that’s really all there is to it but, in the hands of such a fine writer, one is drawn into their rather prosaic world and spends a delightful time in their company.
Robyn Wheldall

My reading life of late has had a common theme; the way in which individuals deal with their mortality, or that of those close to them, and who can tell the stories of those who have died. A rather morbid preoccupation you might think, but when one’s husband has a chronic and incurable cancer it does tend to focus the mind. I was very interested to read Peter Goldsworthy’s The Cancer Finishing School. I was aware of Goldsworthy as a medical doctor and an Australian author and columnist but had never read any of his fiction. Not that The Cancer Finishing School is a work of fiction. Rather, it an autobiographical account of Goldsworthy’s own journey with the blood cancer, myeloma. As this is the same cancer that has been a part of my life for nearly 16 years, I related to his description of his and his loved ones’ response to the diagnosis and the treatment – including an autologous stem-cell transplant which is always scary because the chance of not surviving this treatment is a real threat. There were so many resonances for me that one would think that this made the book appealing. Not so. I found Goldsworthy’s tone rather glib, but the real exception I took was the way in which he described his own patients and some of their journeys. I found this invasive and rather betraying of their trust which I thought, as a medical doctor, he would understand.
This brings me to Anne Patchett’s well-known work Truth and Beauty: A Friendship. This book was published in 2004 and is considered to have added considerable momentum to Patchett’s developing career as an author of note. Disconcerting then, that so many of the details of her close friendship with her recently deceased friend, Lucy Grealy, and the details of her troubled life were disclosed. So distressed were Grealy’s family that they had tried to stop the publication but failed.
It is a compelling memoir (and I am a great fan of Ann Patchett’s writing) but I could not help thinking, ‘what would your friend think of this if she were alive’? Does being a writer give one permission to share intimate secrets and knowledge of one’s friends? This had troubled me about Goldsworthy’s book as well, when he described his own patients so well in his book that they recognised themselves! Who gets to tell other people’s stories?
My faith in the possibility of good coming from a writer telling other people’s stories was restored when I read A Better Death: Conversations About the Art of Living and Dying Well by Dr Ranjana Srivastava, an oncologist, award-winning writer, broadcaster and Fulbright scholar. Writing of her own experience and conversations with her patients, this book was a very sensitive treatment of people’s journeys towards their deaths. This was done respectfully and instructively. It was not morbid but inspiring in the way it gently opened the necessity for us all to think of our own mortality and how we need to live our lives with this in mind. Srivastava’s message is that our modern experience of death and dying has been overly medicalised and hidden away from our everyday experience. We often try to block out thoughts of our own mortality with the confidence in the magnificent advances that have been made in medical science. As grateful as we are for these, this does not take away from the fact that there are the two great certainties of life: birth and death. Srivastava skilfully provides advice on leading a meaningful life and finding dignity and composure at its end. It is a book that should be widely read and re-read.